One day in… GTA V already causing trouble

closeThis article could be out of date, as it was published 1 year 2 months 7 days ago.

So GTA V finally released yesterday on PS3 and Xbox 360, but instead of the murder and gratuitous violence causing issues it is a review by Gamespots’ Carolyn Petit.

Now we all know it would not officially be a decent GTA release without some kind of controversy, but should this be caused by a review score of 9.0?

In fact it appears Carolyn’s review praised the game generally for all the right reasons until she offered her personal views on the game – “hang on” I hear you cry, “isn’t that the job of a game reviewer?”

Yes sane people of the world it would appear game reviewers can no longer offer their own personal insight into a release as Carolyn stated;

“Politically muddled and profoundly misogynistic” “Perhaps you dive right into the game’s story problems, or its serious issues with women.”

Apparently the fact that she has dared to mention the games view point on women (keep in mind the fact that all GTA games are full of hookers) is enough for some gamers to call for her head, with a petition for her sacking already started.

Obviously these views are a reason to fire her right? No, it is a reviewer’s job to offer their opinions and describe what they see as positives or flaws within a game.

This is not the first time Gamespot readers have lost their heads with reviewer Jeff Gerstmann receiving death threats for his review of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

People who are offended by reviews are free not to read them and find another website or publication that suits their viewpoints instead of trying to end the career of somebody who offers a different opinion to their own.

Follow Us
on Google+

Hilton Auckland

As more and more conferences and events arrive in New Zealand, the opportunity to gain knowledge and build networks becomes better every day. Conferences can be hard work, and there’s nothing like retiring to a nice hotel room at the end of the day to relax and rest. But how do you turn a night in a hotel room into a lesson in building brand loyalty?   Read More →

Android App Review: Vimeo

NetGuide I review a lot of apps that, for one reason or another, aren’t that good. But it’s rare to find one that’s actually irredeemably broken. Video sharing website Vimeo’s app, however, is closer than it should be for an app with such obvious potential.   Read More →

Review: Samsung Gear S

NetGuide It takes something pretty special to stand out from the crowd in the smart wearable space. With new smartwatches and bands launching on a weekly basis, there’s lots of noise and plenty of confusion.   Read More →